With an allowance rate of 69%, Madison approves more claims than many other hearing offices. Because the panel of 6 judges maintains a tight spread in their decisions, your outcome is more likely to be determined by the quality of your medical evidence than by the specific judge assigned to your case. Use your 8-month wait to build a comprehensive record that addresses your vocational limitations. An attorney can help you organize your medical evidence to maximize your chances of approval.
Your 8-month wait provides a runway to ensure your medical file is complete before you step into the hearing room. You should prioritize gathering updated records from every specialist you have seen since your initial denial, as these documents are the primary evidence the judge will review. During your hearing, a vocational expert will likely testify about whether jobs exist that accommodate your specific physical or mental limitations. You will have the opportunity to question this expert, making it vital that your daily-activity logs and medication side-effect reports are precise. Ensure all evidence is submitted well before the deadline, as last-minute additions are often restricted.
The panel at this office is notably consistent, with allowance rates for the 5 active judges clustering tightly between 58% and 77%. Because the judges operate within a narrow 19-point band, you can expect a similar standard of evidence regardless of who is assigned to your case. While random assignment is the rule, each judge weighs evidence differently, so your file must be robust enough to stand on its own merits.
Even in an office with a 69% allowance rate, the difference between an approval and a denial often comes down to how well you handle the vocational expert's testimony. When you have months to wait for your hearing, you can use that time to identify gaps in your medical record that a judge might otherwise view as a lack of evidence. A professional review of your file can ensure you are ready to answer questions about your daily limitations under oath.
With 1,848 dispositions in the latest reporting period, this office manages a high volume of claims; keep these location details handy for your hearing day.
Madison, WI
| Rank | Judge | Approval Rate | Full Approval | Total Decisions | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Debra Meachum | 78% | 66% | 18,122 | |
| 2 | Joseph D. Jacobson | 71% | 70% | 30,836 | |
| 3 | Thomas W. Springer | 70% | 60% | 8,142 | |
| 4 | Ahavaha Pyrtel | 68% | 59% | 22,030 | |
| 5 | Michael Schaefer | 62% | 60% | 26,088 | |
| 6 | Gary A. Freyberg | 58% | 50% | 18,003 | |
| 7 | John H. Pleuss | 54% | 46% | 1,893 | |
| 8 | Guila Parker | 49% | 51% | 20,940 |
SSDI hearing approval rates — with a lawyer vs. on your own
Source: U.S. Government Accountability Office, GAO-18-37 — analysis of SSA ALJ adult disability decisions, FY 2007–2015. Applicants with a lawyer got approved at a rate nearly three times higher than those without. Individual case outcomes vary based on medical evidence, the specific judge, and quality of representation. Checking whether you qualify for a free benefits review takes 2 minutes.
Average months from hearing request to decision — last 16 months
Where to apply or check on your claim in person
About This Content
Statistics come from SSA's Office of Hearings Operations reports and publicly available judge decision data. Approval rates count both full and partial approvals. Wait times reflect the average from hearing request to decision.